Criminal law
Reclassifying the charge: Italian criminal defence
Not every courtroom win is an acquittal. Sometimes the decisive defence work is about how the facts are classified, not only whether they happened.
Not every win in court is an acquittal. A defence lawyer’s job is not only to seek an acquittal but to make sure each person is judged for what has actually been proven at trial. Sometimes that means working on the correct legal classification of the facts: how they are framed, not only whether they happened.
What “classifying” the facts means
The same incident can amount to different offences, with very different penalties. Common examples:
- robbery, or theft followed by a push while running away;
- serious or minor injury, depending on how long the victim was unwell;
- ordinary drug dealing or a minor offence under Article 73(5) of the drugs law;
- fraud, or a simple breach of contract, which is not a crime.
The classification affects the sentence, whether the case needs a victim’s complaint to proceed, limitation periods, access to alternatives to prison and to plea-type procedures.
The judge’s power and its limits
An Italian judge may give the facts a different legal classification from the prosecution’s, as long as the facts stay the same and the offence is not for a higher court (Article 521 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). If different facts emerge, the file goes back to the prosecutor.
There is a vital safeguard: the defence must be able to argue against the new classification. The European Court of Human Rights (Drassich v. Italy, 2007) and Italy’s Supreme Court have made clear that the accused must have the chance to defend themselves on it, not discover it for the first time in the judgment.
Work that continues at every stage
Classification is debated during the investigation, when strategy is set; at first instance, with evidence and argument; on appeal and before the Court of Cassation, where misclassification is a ground of appeal. A reclassification can mean a much lighter sentence, the offence becoming time-barred, or the case being dropped for lack of a complaint.
A matter of fairness
A rigorous defence is first and foremost a guarantee of fairness: being convicted of a more serious offence than the one committed is an injustice, even when some facts are admitted. If you have just been served papers, see notice of investigation in Italy: the first 48 hours.
I defend clients in English, Italian and Albanian. More on criminal law, including in Pistoia, Florence and Prato.